The Vial Poured Out Upon the Sea
In May 1726 the boatswain William Fly threw his captain into the sea, took four vessels in a month, and was carried into Boston in irons by the forced men of his own crew. He was among the last pirates of the Golden Age.
show moreshow less
Cotton Mather went to the prison to collect the confession that always came, and to print it. Fly gave him nothing. He denied the charge as laid, would not be led to the meeting house, and used what he was told would be his last words to advise the shipmasters in the crowd to treat their crews better and pay them what they were owed. At the gallows he told the hangman he was no craftsman and retied the noose himself.
Mather printed all of it anyway. The most articulate refusal any Golden Age pirate ever made survives only inside the tract written to bury it.
He also left a great deal out. The trial gets a single sentence. Twelve acquittals go unmentioned. Three men named in the indictment as principals in the killing were never brought to trial at all, and the ship’s own new name never appears in fifty-one pages.
This expanded edition prints the pamphlet entire and fills its gaps from five other sources: the complete trial record, the narrative Benjamin Colman took from the pilot who retook the ship, and the London printings that recorded what Boston did not.
or take a copy on paper